July 2005, Volume 27, No. 7
Editorial

The greatest irony of all

Rudolph W M Chow 周偉文

A five-year-old boy by the name of "Sze Wai" (思瑋) attended my clinic one evening. He had been seen by my colleagues several times in the past few years, usually accompanied by his mother and the domestic helper. The mother-child interaction soon drew my attention. The child was obviously not very subordinate but at the same time seemed unusually attached to his mother. While I was examining the boy, I casually asked the mother if he was the only child. His mother calmly replied that he used to have an elder brother who was born with a serious congenital heart condition and did not live past his second birthday. She added that that child had seen us before. After I finished work that day, I dug up the deceased brother's record by searching through the home telephone number. I found an empty record with a registration date and appointment time but the child did not turn up for the consultation. I worked out from the boys' birthdays that their mother became pregnant in her first child's last year of life and the younger brother was born shortly after his elder brother died. The two boys, destined to be brothers, narrowly missed the chance to lay eyes on each other. I looked at the name of the deceased child and it said "Man Wai" (文瑋); it struck me then that the boy I was seeing was named after his elder brother. For readers who are not familiar with the Chinese language, the word "Sze" () could mean "to think of", "to be reminiscent of" and "to feel the loss of". A name endowed with memories and sorrow for their sadly lost first child, sentiments that only parents can fully comprehend.

I believe that one of the greatest things that a parent does for his child is to name him. For by that name, he finds his place in the world as an individual and earns his first identity. Many parents will recall the lengths they went into naming their first child. Do we know why our own parents gave us our particular name? What kind of expectations or blessings did they put into that very name? As bearer of that name, what kind of person our parents had hoped we would grow up to be? Those of us who are fortunate enough to have our parents with us may want to find out the answers at our next family gathering, which, unfortunately, may be few and far between. Professor Young hit the spot when she commented that doctors tend to pursue their professional goals at the expense of other more personal goals.1

Family support is an important prognostic factor in many conditions seen in primary care. We try to convince patients and their families of this everyday and we believe in it; why, then, should we ourselves be any different? Effective practice of Family Medicine does not exist in isolation but is the end product of many influences including the doctor's own family. I think I learn just as much, out of teaching my boy how to ride his first bike than attending a workshop, on parenting problems. I think the commonest parenting problem in Hong Kong is that "parenting" does not exist; parents are simply not there to parent their children. I know I will never be able to gain CPD points for spending time with my family because such activities will be considered outside my "professional" life. Deep down in my heart I choose to believe that, in many ways, my family teaches me how to be a better doctor.

Doctors who take "family" as their motto and call themselves Family Physicians, end up neglecting their own families and leading a miserable family life is, to me, the greatest irony of all.


Rudolph W M Chow, MBBS(NSW), FHKCFP, FRACGP
Family Physician in Private Practice.

Correspondence to : Dr Rudolph W M Chow, Shop 23-26, G/F, Tuen Mun Town Plaza, Phase II, Tuen Mun, N.T., Hong Kong.


References
  1. Young D. Dr Sun Yat-Sen Oration 2005: Balancing professional and personal goals in a medical career. HK Pract 2005;27:197-201