February 2002, Vol 24, No. 2
Update Articles

Causal agents, clinical presentation and management of fungal skin and nail infections

D T Roberts, F A Campbell

HK Pract 2002;24:72-82

Summary

Fungal infections are amongst the commonest of all skin diseases. They vary from relatively trivial scaling between the toes to widespread disease of the scalp, skin and nails. These can be treated by modern and effective drugs providing the diagnosis is accurately made, particularly in cases where systemic treatment is indicated. In some cases a clinical diagnosis is sufficient but laboratory confirmation is necessary where treatment duration is lengthy or where there is a significant treatment failure rate..

摘要

真菌感染是最常見的皮膚疾病,形式從輕微的趾 間脫皮到頭皮、皮膚和指(趾)甲的廣泛感染而變化多樣。只要診斷正確,都可以用新而有效的藥物治療,尤其是需要系統治療的病例。有些病例僅需臨床診斷足以,但當治療周期較長或治療無效率較高時,則需要實驗室診斷確認。


Introduction

Although over 100,000 species of fungi have been described in nature, fewer than 200 are recognised as single pathogens and many of these are only pathogenic as a result of diminished host defence. Superficial infection of the skin and mucous membranes are predominantly caused by dermatophyte moulds, Candida yeasts and Pityrosporum yeasts. Dermatophyte moulds are primary pathogens whereas Candida and Pityrosporum yeasts are known commensals of the mucous membranes and skin respectively and are nearly always secondary pathogens.

Dermatophyte infection

Dermatophytes may be anthropophilic, where humans are the primary host; zoophilic which have animals as the primary host; or geophilic where the fungus exists in the soil. Specific zoophilic dermatophytes tend to confine themselves to a single animal, or at most a small number of different animal species.

All three varieties of dermatophyte are capable of causing disease in humans, but anthropophilic species produce the bulk of infections and are better adapted to existence on humans; for this reason anthropophilic dermatophytes tend to induce much less of an inflammatory response than do zoophilic or geophilic varieties and therefore produce more chronic disease. Trichophyton rubrum and the anthropophilic variant of Trichophyton mentagrophytes (sometimes known as Trichophyton interdigitalae) are the commonest cause of dermatophyte infection and usually affect the toeclefts, nails and groin area as well as the trunk and lower extremities. Zoophilic dermatophytes most often produce infection in sites exposed to contact with animals such as the scalp, face, hands and arms. Dermatophyte infections are often known as "tinea" or "ringworm" infections. Both of these terms refer to the annular or ring like appearance of the skin lesions which have a raised scaly edge and a healing center, although the clinical appearance will vary according to the site affected even when the same fungi are involved. Thus, there remains some utility in using the anatomical classification of infection, viz: tinea capitis (scalp), tinea corporis (trunk and limbs), tinea cruris (groin), tinea pedis (feet and toeclefts) and tinea unguum (nails). This anatomical classification does not imply infection with any specific type of dermatophyte and any dermatophyte can cause disease in any of the above sites. Identification of the species of dermatophyte is, however, of importance in that it will help to identify the vector. For example, Microsporum canis infection always arises from cats or dogs whereas Trichophyton verrucosum always tends to come from cattle or sheep. If an anthropophilic species is identified then infection must be from human to human, although this can be via inanimate objects such as furniture, clothing or most often the floors of communal bathing places.

Tinea capitis

Figure 1: Diagram showing the methods of fungal invasion of the hair shaft


Figure 2: Tinea capitis of the dry type caused by M. canis infection


Figure 3: Tinea capitis of the kerion type caused by T. verrucosum infection


Figure 4: Tinea corporis showing a typical scaly edge and healing centre


Figure 5: Widespread tinea corporis


Figure 6: Tinea cruris


Figure 7: Tinea pedis showing maceration and a fissure in the toecleft


Figure 8: Fungal nail infection showing subungual hyperkeratosis


Figure 9: Fungal nail infection showing thickening and discolouration of the nail plate


Figure 10: Oral candidosis or "denture sore mouth"


Figure 11: Seborrhoeic dermatitis showing greasy scale in the nasolabial fold


Figure 12: Pityriasis versicolor in light skin


Figure 13: Pityriasis versicolor in dark skin

Infection of the scalp can occur in one of three ways (Figure 1) and is dependent upon the species of dermatophyte involved. Ectothrix infections occur when both the inside and the outside of the hair shaft are invaded and Microsporum canis, Microsporum audouinii, Trichophyton mentagrophytes and Trichophyton verrucosum can cause this type of infection. Ectothrix infections are clinically very obvious and occur as a dry scaling patch of alopecia (M. canis, M. audouinii) or as boggy inflammatory swelling known as a kerion (T. verrucosum, T. mentagrophytes). Endothrix infections where only the inside of the hair shaft is invaded are often much more discrete although chronic infection will ultimately lead to a good deal of alopecia. Trichophyton tonsurans, Trichophyton violaceum and Trichophyton sudanense are all common endothrix infections. The thirdtype of hair invasion is known as favus and is caused by the single dermatophyte Trichophyton schoenleinii. The type of invasion here is unique to this fungus and results in the inside of the hair shaft containing both fungal elements and significant air pockets which gives rise to cup shaped crusts known as scutula. Favus is now a relatively uncommon disease seen only in third world countries although may still occasionally exist in long-stay institutions such as mental hospitals, children's homes, prisons and in the military.

Zoophilic scalp infection regularly occurs in a sporadic fashion; Microsporum canis (Figure 2) and Trichophyton verrucosum (Figure 3) are the commonest species seen simply because they have domestic animals as primary hosts. The prevalence of anthropophilic infection has varied considerably over the past century. Prior to the advent of systemic antidermatophyte agents, the only method of treatment was epilation. Although effective, patients were not happy to volunteer for such treatment and disease prevalence remained quite high. The introduction of the drug griseofulvin in the late 1950's revolutionised the treatment of scalp infection and rendered epilation unnecessary. As a result anthro-pophilic scalp ringworm secondary to Microsporum audouinii became very much less common in the developed world although the incidence remained, and still remains, high in countries where drug availability is limited. Tricophyton violaceum, an ectothrix infection found in the Middle East, the Indian subcontinent and parts of the Far East has always been fairly prevalent, and has spread much more widely following immigration patterns. More recently, Trichophyton tonsurans infection, which is also endothrix, has reached almost endemic proportions in a number of western countries, notably the USA and the UK.1 The reasons for this are not entirely clear although the disease is certainly most common in patients of afro-caribbean origin. This fungus produces the so-called "black dot" variety of scalp ringworm where the hair breaks off at the scalp surface leaving small dark areas which represent the mouth of hair follicles.

Zoophilic species produce a much greater inflammatory response and this often results in a boggy inflammatory swelling known as a kerion, which is mistreated as a bacterial abscess. This invariably leads to an area of scarring alopecia as the kerion resolves. It is therefore important to consider a fungus as a cause of any abscess like swelling of the scalp or indeed other sites, particularly when the lesion is multiheaded. The pus contained within such lesions is rich in fungal elements which can easily be visualised microscopically. Early intervention with antifungal drugs is generally effective and helps to minimise the risk of scarring.

Tinea corporis

Infection of the glabrous skin of the trunk and limbs is usually the result of an anthropophilic or zoophilic infection. Typically the lesions are ring like with a raised scaling edge and a healing centre (Figure 4). The edge can be irregular and untreated lesions can become very large (Figure 5). Sometimes, satellite lesions, which are also annular, develop beyond the edge of the main lesion. Untreated disease may eventually involve almost the whole of the trunk and limbs and give rise to chronic itch.

Annular psoriasis, discoid eczema, pityriasis rosea, granuloma annulare and other annular erythemas are all included in the differential diagnosis. Almost all of these are best treated by topical steroids and the misdiagnosis and mistreatment of Tinea corporis with topical steroids leads to a reduction in itch and scaling, loss of integrity of the ring like edge and the development of granuloma like nodules. This renders the diagnosis even more difficult. Although Tinea corporis is probably over diagnosed and treated with topical antifungal agents, this is a lesser sin than treating a fungal infection with a topical steroid. Topical antifungal drugs will not cause other dermatoses to deteriorate as is the case with topical steroids in fungal infections.

The disease known as Tinea imbricata is worthy of mention simply because it occurs entirely in the tropics and is widespread in Asia, the Pacific Islands and south and central America.2 It is not endemic to Hong Kong but is to certain parts of nearby countries and may therefore conceivably be seen in travellers to the region. It is caused by a single dermatophyte known as Trichophyton concentricum and produces a specific clinical appearance whereby concentric rings develop in each lesion. Each ring is scaly and slightly infiltrated and they can become multiple until eventually the whole body is covered by this extremely bizarre and unique eruption.

Tinea cruris

This disease affects the groin area although theoretically the axillae may also be involved (Figure 6). In temperate countries it is a disease almost entirely confined to males but does occur in females in tropical climates. It is caused almost entirely by anthropophilic dermatophytes which spread from the toeclefts. Trichophyton rubrum, T. mentagrophytes and Epidermo-phyton floccosum are usually causal.

Flexural infected eczema, intertrigo, psoriasis and erythrasma all can have similar clinical appearances and the same therapeutic considerations apply as they do to Tinea corporis.

Tinea pedis

This is the commonest variety of dermatophyte infection and is widely known as athlete's foot. The disease is generally contracted from the floors of communal bathing places. Nowadays, such bathing places are usually leisure facilities, saunas and sports clubs.3 Previously, industrial baths in the coalmining and other heavy industries were a common source of infection. Disease prevalence amongst users of communal bathing places is directly related to frequency of exposure. It follows therefore that prevalence is higher amongst competitive swimmers than amongst regular users who in turn have higher prevalence than casual bathers. Previous studies carried out amongst coalminers suggested a prevalence of around 80% of all workers who have a communal bath once every working day over a lifetime. Regularly used communal bathing places are heavily contaminated with dermatophytes and various studies have revealed the contamination rate to vary between 100 and more then 300 fungal elements per m2 of floor space. Because each of these fungal elements is protected in a small piece of keratin, it is difficult to keep the floors sterile by means of disinfectant which would require to penetrate the keratin and thus be acutely irritant to all users' feet. Foot powders are not useful therapeutically but their use should be encouraged prophylactically.

Tinea pedis almost always affects the fourth toecleft first (Figure 7) and it may remain confined to this site but can sometimes spread to affect all other clefts and eventually the sole and even the dorsum of the foot. When the whole of the foot is involved in this fashion the disease is known as Moccasin tinea pedis.

Tinea unguum

Tinea unguum known as onychomycosis or fungal nail infection results from a spread of the fungus from the toeclefts or soles into the nails. The disease begins at the hyponychium, often laterally rather than centrally, and spreads slowly but relentlessly down the nail bed resulting in separation of the nail plate from the nail bed (onycholysis) and the development of marked subungual hyperkeratosis (Figure 8). Eventually the disease will reach the proximal nail fold and thereafter involve the nail plate (Figure 9) itself resulting in gross thickening, discolouration and occasionally complete destruction of the nail plate. Toenails are affected in about 80% of all cases of onychomycosis but the disease can spread from the toeclefts to the fingernails.4

Dermatophytes, usually T. rubrum, cause 90% of all cases of onychomycosis. Yeast infection secondary to Candida albicans occurs mostly in the fingernails and generally results from separation of the cuticle from the nail plate resulting in chronic paronychia and subsequently nail dystrophy. There has been much debate about the role of non dermatophyte moulds in onychomycosis and there is little evidence that they are primary pathogens but they are well capable of invading already dystrophic nails in a saprophytic fashion. This does not however mean that their eradication will result in any improvement in the clinical appearance as they are behaving simply as saprophytes. In such cases the commonest cause of the primary nail damage is usually a dermatophyte infection although trauma and other nail diseases may be implicated.

The geophilic mould Scytalidium dimidiatum (formerly known as Hendersonula toruloidea) is undoubtedly a primary pathogen of nail in that it is the only non dermatophyte mould which is capable of causing Tinea pedis and is the commonest cause of Tinea pedis in some parts of South East Asia, notably Thailand and it does not appear susceptible to antifungal drugs. It produces a typical black discolouration of the nails.5

Yeast infection

Both Candida yeasts and pityrosporum yeasts can cause disease of the skin and mucous membranes in certain circumstances.

Candidiasis

Candida yeasts are predominantly commensals of the mouth, vagina and GI tract and have a predilection for mucous membranes. Only under certain circumstances of diminished host defence do they cause disease in these sites. Cutaneous candidiasis is virtually unknown in immunocompetent individuals although diabetics and occasionally patients on antibiotics may develop flexural candidiasis which can be submammary, axillary or occur in the groin area. The lesions are clinically fairly typical and white plaques are seen at the edge of inflammatory lesions.

Oral candidiasis is sometimes the result of long-term antibiotic therapy but is most often seen in patients with dentures who do not sterilise them in a proper fashion and chronic oral candidiasis, known as "denture sore mouth" results (Figure 10).

Vulvovaginal candidiasis is generally outwith the scope of an article on the skin manifestations of fungal disease. It can also occur in diabetics and patients on antibiotics but a significant number of females suffer from recurrent vulvovaginal candidiasis who have no obvious predisposing factors. It is assumed that they have a subtle defect in their host defences to yeasts which result in chronic and distressing disease. It is difficult to eradicate but is usually controllable with the right treatment.

Pityrosporum yeast infection

Pityrosporum yeasts are a complex group of organisms, the classification of which is constantly changing. Many now recognise these yeasts as a variety of the Malassezia group. They are often commensals of the scalp and exist asymptomatically in small numbers. Where they overgrow they initially produce scaling of the scalp (dandruff) and ultimately can spread to produce inflammatory lesions of the face, specifically the eyebrows, eyelashes and nasolabial folds (Figure 11). This condition is known as seborrhoeic dermatitis and/or seborrhoeic blepharitis. The cause is not entirely clear but pityrosporum yeasts are lipophilic and therefore tend to affect patients with greasy skins. On the trunk, psoriasiform lesions can develop in the mid chest, usually in males, and is known as petaloid seborrhoeic dermatitis. A low-grade folliculitis sometimes develops, more often in males than females and is known as pityrosporum folliculitis.

The disease known as Pityriasis versicolor is also related to pityrosporum yeast infection and may result from a yeast mycelial shift which occurs sometimes in organisms of this group. Pityriasis versicolor is an interesting condition which can involve the whole of the trunk and the limbs in a "vest and pants" distribution if left untreated. The lesions are primarily a pale cream/ brown colour and appear dark in patients with white skin (Figure 12) and much lighter patients with brown or black skins (Figure 13). In addition the fungus produces azeleic acid which is in itself depigmenting and therefore white areas remain even after successful treatment. Pityriasis versicolor tends to occur most often in hot, sweaty conditions which may be either climatic or occupational. It is not a difficult condition to treat providing the diagnosis is accurately made.6

Diagnosis of fungal infections

Diagnosis is suspected clinically and confirmed by laboratory examination of specimens by microscopy and culture. Ideally this procedure should be followed in all cases, but it must be recognised that, for much of the time, diagnosis is confirmed by therapeutic trial rather than by laboratory tests. There is some utility in this pragmatic approach so long as its limitations are recognised.

Where systemic treatment is prescribed it is as well, for medicolegal as well as medical reasons, to obtain laboratory confirmation of infection. This applies to infection of the scalp, widespread disease of the body and groin and to nail infection. The quality of laboratory diagnosis depends largely upon the quality of the specimen submitted and specimens should be taken as outlined below:

  • Specimens from the scalp should include scale from the edge of the lesion together with some hairs and hair follicles. Hairs from within or at the edge of the lesion should be gripped with the forceps and pulled out by the roots and the whole hair submitted along with the skin scales. If a kerion is present then a swab of the pus should be sent to the laboratory along with the skin and hair specimens.
  • In Tinea corporis and Tinea cruris scrapings should be taken with a scalpel blade from the scaly edge of the lesion, scraping from in to out. It is sometimes easier to soak the area in saline first and the resulting slurry deposited on the black paper specimen container.
  • Fungal nail infection is predominantly a disease of the nail bed and as much of the subungual debris as possible should be obtained preferably from the most proximal area of infection. A fine dental scraper is very good for this purpose. If necessary the nail can be cut back in order to facilitate collection of the specimen. A thickened piece of nail can be included as well.

Small areas of Tinea corporis, Tinea cruris and athlete's foot confined to the toeclefts generally respond well to one or two weeks treatment with a potent topical antifungal agent. Other inflammatory dermatoses which may look similar do not respond at all.

Yeast infections are generally commensal organisms and there is usually little to be gained from laboratory confirmation of infection. Pityriasis versicolor is the exception and is easily diagnosed by microscopy of skin scrapings. The yeast is lipophilic and difficult to grow in culture which is therefore not necessary to confirm the diagnosis. Because the cosmetic appearance takes much longer to resolve than does the infection itself it is politic to confirm the diagnosis and therefore reassure the patient that the treatment has been correct and will ultimately be effective. Scrapings should be taken in similar fashion to those taken from patients with Tinea corporis.

Treatment of fungal infections

There are two important considerations, namely the choice of topical or oral treatment and thereafter drug selection. Treatment recommendations are outlined in Tables 1 and 2.

Table 1: Topical treatment
Disease Drug* Duration
Tinea corporis Terbinafine cream
Clotrimazole cream
Miconazole cream
2 weeks
4 weeks
4 weeks
Tinea cruris Terbinafine cream
Clotrimazole cream
Miconazole cream
2 weeks
4 weeks
4 weeks
Tinea pedis (interdigital) Clotrimazole cream
Miconazole cream
Terbinafine cream

2 weeks
4 weeks
4 weeks

Cutaneous candidiasis Terbinafine cream
Clotrimazole cream
Miconazole cream
4 weeks
4 weeks
4 weeks
Oral candidiasis+ Miconazole gel
Nystatin oral suspension
Nystatin pastels
Amphotericin lozenges
Amphotericin suspension


1-2 weeks
1 week
1 week
2 weeks
2 weeks
* There are a large number of different topical azole preparations available. It is unlikely that their treatment durations differ.
+ In practice treatment durations for oral candidiasis will be variable depending upon the cause. All treatments should be continued for 48 hours after the disappearance of signs and symptoms.


Table 2: Systemic treatment
Disease Drug Dose (daily) Duration
Tinea capitis* Griseofulvin 1 - 1.5g (adults)
8 - 16 weeks
10 - 20mg/kg (children) 8 - 16 weeks
Terbinafine 250mg (adults) 2 - 4 weeks
62.5mg (<20kg) 2 - 4 weeks
125mg (20 - 40kg) 2 - 4 weeks
250mg (>40kg) 2 - 4 weeks
Tinea corporis/cruris Griseofulvin 500mg
4 weeks
Terbinafine 250mg 1 - 2 weeks
Itraconazole 100mg 4 weeks
200mg 2 weeks
Tinea pedis/manuum Griseofulvin
1g
8 weeks
Terbinafine 250mg 2 weeks
Itraconazole 400mg 1 week
Tinea unguum Griseofulvin 1g 6 - 9 months (fingernails)
12 - 18 months (toenails)
Terbinafine 250mg 6 weeks (fingernails)
12 weeks (toenails)
Itraconazole 200mg 12 weeks
400mg for 1 week x 2-3 (fingernails)
400mg for 1 week x 3-4 (toenails)
Pityriasis versicolor Itraconazole 200mg 7 days
Candida nails+ Itraconazole 200mg

6 - 12 weeks depending upon underlying condition


* Treatment durations for T. capitis vary with the type of infection and the individual affected. Efficacy should be monitored by regular clinical examination and repeated mycology.
+ Fluconazole is a useful and widely used drug in candidiasis. However, it has not been evaluated for Candida nail infection.

Dermatophyte infection

Systemic treatment of dermatophytosis is indicated if the site of infection is in an area where the keratin turnover time is lengthy i.e. scalp, palms, soles and nails or if there is extensive involvement of the body surface. Topical treatment is entirely adequate for the toeclefts and small areas of Tinea corporis/cruris. Terbinafine is the most potent antidermatophyte agent available7 and is marketed in both systemic and topical formulations. Its potency has been confirmed in both in vitro and in vivo tests.

Yeast infections

Oral and cutaneous candidiasis can generally be treated topically unless there is very widespread involvement or the disease is particularly recalcitrant because of intercurrent factors. A topical azole is probably the best choice. Topical terbinafine is effective in yeast infections but the number of formulations available is fewer. Systemic terbinafine is not active against Candida albicans and systemic azoles such as fluconazole or itraconazole are the best choice.

Pityrosporum yeast infections are sometimes multifactorial, e.g. seborrhoeic dermatitis and are best treated with combinations of steroids and antifungals. Where the yeast alone is the only factor, e.g. Pityriasis versicolor and perhaps pityrosporum folliculitis then a systemic rather than topical agent is the best choice simply because of disease extent. Again a systemic azole is likely to be the most effective choice.

Key messages

  1. Fungal infections mimic many other dermatoses and effective treatment depends upon the correct diagnosis.
  2. Although a therapeutic trial of an antifungal to confirm the diagnosis is occasionally acceptable, in those areas which respond quickly to topical treatment, laboratory identification of the fungus is usually necessary.
  3. Topical treatment should be chosen initially but only in those areas known to respond to topical therapy.
  4. Diseases of the scalp, palms, soles and nails always require systemic treatment.

D T Roberts, MBChB, FRCP(Glasg)
Consultant Dermatologist and Honorary Clinical Senior Lecturer,
South Glasgow University Hospitals NHS Trust, U.K.

F A Campbell, MBChB, FRCP(Glasg), MRCGP, DRCOG
Principal in General Practice and Hospital Practitioner in Dermatology,
Southern General Hospital and Victoria Infirmary, U.K.

Correspondence to : Dr D T Roberts, Consultant Dermatologist and Honorary Clinical Senior Lecturer, South Glasgow University Hospitals NHS Trust, Southern General Hospital, Glasgow G51 4TF, U.K.


References
  1. Bronson DN, Desaid R, Bharsky S. An epidemic of infection with Trichophyton tonsurans reviewed a 20 year survey of fungal infections in Chicago.
    J Am Acad Dermatol
    1983;8:322-330.
  2. McLennan R, O'Keefe M. Altitude and prevalence of Tinea imbracata in New Guinea.
    Trans Roys Soc Trop Med Hyg
    1975;69:91-93.
  3. Gentles JC, Evans EGV, Jones GR. Control of Tinea pedis in the swimming bath.
    BMJ
    1974;2:577-580.
  4. Baran R, Dawber R, Haneke E, et al. Onychomycosis and its treatment. In: A text atlas of nail disorders. Martin Dunitz, London. 1996;155-167.
  5. Summerbell RC, Kane J, Krajden S. Onychomycosis, Tinea pedis and Tinea Manuum caused by non dermatophyte filamentous fungi.
    Mycoses
    1989;32:609-619.
  6. Faergemann J. Pityrosporum infections.
    J Am Acad Dermatol
    1994;31(3 Part 2):S18-S20.
  7. Clayton YM. Relevance of broad spectrum and fungicidal activity of antifungals in the treatment of dermatomycosis.
    Br J Dermatol
    1994;130(Suppl 43):7-8.