Chemical pathology case conference - heavy metals
Michael H M Chan 陳浩明, Robert C K Cheung 張志強, Albert Y W Chan 陳恩和, Eric C W Lam 林青雲,
Tony W L Mak 麥永禮, Anthony C C Shek 石志忠, Sidney Tam 譚志輝, Christopher W K Lam 林偉基
HK Pract 2005;27:94-102
Summary
The term "heavy metals" should have been reserved for those metallic elements with
an atomic mass of 200 or above, such as mercury (200), thallium (204), lead (207)
and bismuth (209). However, it would be clinically relevant to include some lighter
metals such as aluminium (27), arsenic (75), cadmium (112), cobalt (59) exposure
to which is clinically undesirable and constitutes a health hazard. Heavy metals
are normally present in biological fluids and tissues at very low concentrations
[<100mg/g or part per million (ppm)] that are often below the detection limit of
early analytical methods, and therefore also called "trace metals". The latter term
generally also includes "essential trace metals", which are (i) naturally available
in our diet, (ii) present in the body at relatively constant concentrations, (iii)
physiologically important, and (iv) pathogenic if deficient. "Trace elements" is
perhaps a more appropriate term if reference is made to include both metals and
non-metals such as iodine, bromine and silicon. In this case conference, the biochemical
profiles for a series of clinical cases are used to illustrate the precautions in
the patient and sample preparations for metal analysis, the proper interpretation
of the laboratory results, as well as the principles of investigation in patients
suspected of heavy metal intoxication.
摘要
重金屬通常指金屬元素原子量大於或等於200或以上的金屬,例如水銀、鉈、鉛和鉍。 然而,臨床上亦包括某些原子量較輕的元素,如鋁、砷、鎘和鈷,可以因為過度接觸而導致不良反應,
危害健康。正常情況下,體液和組織中的重金屬濃度非常低〔<100毫克/克或百萬分之一(ppm)〕, 早期分析方法難以測出,故稱為微量金屬。其中包括必需的微量金屬,是指(i)經飲食自然吸收,
(ii)體內濃度相對穩定,(iii)生理上有重要性,(iv)如果缺乏會引致疾病。 微量元素涵蓋了金屬和非金屬元素(如碘、溴、矽),是更恰當的名稱。這次臨床會議,
展示了這類病例的一系列生化特點,說明了病人和樣品準備的預防措施,闡述了懷疑重金屬中毒者檢查結果分析的原則。
Introduction
In recent years, there have been increasing number of locally reported cases of
heavy metal poisoning due to worsening environmental pollution1 or contamination,
as well as a heightened alertness of the lay public and medical practitioners by
the repeated warnings from overseas and local health authorities.2,3
Heavy metal poisoning can be associated with accidental over-exposure from industrial,
dietary, drug-related, or even cosmetics-related sources. Signs and symptoms of
heavy metal poisoning are usually subtle and not well defined because the effect
of heavy metal toxicity can vary from gastrointestinal upset to severe neurological
damage. The mechanism of this wide range of toxicity is due to the covalent binding
of heavy metals to sulphydryl groups at the active site of important enzymes in
various organ systems causing loss of function.4
Due to the difficulty in clinical diagnosis, laboratory screening for heavy metals
is commonly requested for the diagnostic work-up of patients suspected of poisoning.
However, the screening of heavy metals using a correct sample type is also of prime
importance to the subsequent clinical diagnosis and management. Hair is of no doubt
a convenient sample that may reflect recent exposure. However, contamination of
hair samples with air particles, dust, wave and colouring treatments is commonly
encountered.5,6 Moreover, the measurement errors contributed by weighing
the hair samples will be enormous if only a few roots are collected for analysis.
There is a recent report of three local paediatric patients with a questionable
diagnosis of heavy metal poisoning purely based on hair analysis whom unnecessary
chelation therapy had been prescribed.7 In view of the above pre-analytical
variables in hair analysis and the potential harmful effects of unnecessary chelation
therapy, the Hong Kong College of Paediatricians has issued a position paper in
which the use of hair as sample for heavy metal analysis is not recommended.8
Therefore, laboratory diagnosis of heavy metal poisoning should rely on properly
collected blood and urine samples.
Does high urinary arsenic concentration always indicate poisoning?
Arsenic is a very toxic chemical in its trioxide form with an oral lethal dose of
about 3mg/kg of body weight when taken acutely. Exposure to arsenic compounds is
usually industrial as arsenic is used in the manufacture of glass, pigment, wood
preservative, and semiconductors. Sometimes it is used in homicidal attempts. One
of the Indonesian human-right activists was recently poisoned with arsenic during
a flight to Netherlands via Singapore.9 Arsenic is also used therapeutically
in both traditional Chinese medicine10 [in the form of realgar (雄黃, arsenic
sulphide)] for the treatment of peptic ulcer, as an antidote for snake or scorpion
bite via external application, and in western medicine for the treatment of acute
promyelocytic leukaemia.
Acute exposure can give symptoms of headache, nausea, and severe gastrointestinal
upset accompanied with intense abdominal pain, vomiting, and diarrhoea. If left
untreated, dehydration followed by oliguria and circulatory collapse with encephalopathy
and death will supervene. Chronic exposure causes gastrointestinal discomfort, thick
erythematous areas of skin and pruritic pinpoint dermatitis, alopecia, and peripheral
neuropathy. Patients with chronic exposure have an increased risk of developing
carcinoma of the skin and lungs. After initial exposure, arsenic quickly enters
and leaves the systemic circulation. Therefore, exposure is best diagnosed and monitored
by its urinary excretion rate if a timed urine collection is available or its urine
concentration normalised to the creatinine concentration.
Case 1
In a survey of local normal reference interval for spot urine arsenic concentration,
the following results were obtained from 5 ostensibly healthy teachers in a secondary
school:
Subject
|
Arsenic concentration (normal <68nmol/mmol creatinine)11
|
1
|
374
|
2
|
83
|
3
|
37
|
4
|
116
|
5
|
99
|
All teachers denied previous exposure to arsenic compounds in their workplace, nor
having taken any Chinese medicine recently.
Interpretation
Urine arsenic excretion was elevated in all teachers except one. They worked together
in the same environment but lived separately. With a negative occupational history,
it is unusual to find such high prevalence of arsenic over-exposure. The cause of
elevated urinary arsenic concentration is likely to be dietary. Non-toxic organic
compounds of arsenic (arsenobetaine and arsenocholine) are well absorbed in the
gut and abundant in seafood, particularly fish and shellfish. After a seafood meal,
urine output of arsenic may increase substantially to about 50 times above normal
values for the first day before the organic arsenic is completely excreted in the
second days without any toxic effects.4 The abnormal results in this
instance have been caused by the recruitment personnel forgetting to remind volunteers
of the pre-analytical precaution of abstaining from seafood for 5 days before urine
collection.12 The urinalysis should therefore be repeated with proper
dietary preparation. When this patient preparation is not practicable, such as for
urgent investigation of a suspected case of acute poisoning, or forensic examination
of a post mortem sample, speciation of inorganic and organic arsenic is available
from specialist centres.13
My serum aluminium concentration is high, do I suffer from dementia?
Aluminium is widely distributed in our environment. Food and beverages contain a
small amount of aluminium so that our daily dietary intake is estimated at about
5mg/kg of body weight. In some developed countries, the problem of acid rain may
increase the solution of aluminium from soil, thereby contaminating the underground
drinking water. Fortunately, gastrointestinal absorption of this metal is less than
1% in healthy individuals. Any absorbed aluminium will be excreted in the urine
except in the lung tissue, where the macrophages retain aluminium-containing particles
by phagocytosis.
Upon absorption aluminium is transported to every part of our body by transferrin
in the systemic circulation. After crossing the blood-brain barrier, it acts as
a neurotoxin. In the 1970s, patients with renal failure accumulated aluminium through
dialysis therapy. Aluminium contaminated dialysis fluid was found to cause this
dialysis encephalopathy.14 Exposure of aluminium is best diagnosed by
measuring its concentration in serum or blood since it is equally distributed in
plasma and erythrocytes.
Case 2
Aluminium was requested as a part of the investigation of a 55-year old woman who
had normal renal function complaining of increasing forgetfulness for 3 months.
Serum Aluminium 10.8
Reference range:12
0.4 in subjects with normal renal function
<2.2 slight risk of toxicity in chronic renal failure
>2.2 excessive accumulation: risk of toxicity in children
>3.7 cause of concern: risk of toxicity in children
>7.4 high risk of toxicity in all patients
Interpretation
No pre-analytical precautions on blood sampling procedures had been given to the
attending clinician by the laboratory. Consequently, an uncertified clotted blood
bottle was used for the collection of this blood sample. In a specialist trace element
laboratory, proper blood collection precautions and acid-washed specimen bottles
are issued to ensure the quality of the blood sample, as environmental contamination
of aluminium using non-acid-washed specimen bottles is very common. This patient
was found to suffer from hypothyroidism documented with elevation of serum thyroid
stimulating hormone (TSH) to 18.0 mIU/L (normal 0.3-4.2). A repeat blood sample
collected in an acid-wash clotted blood tube showed a normal aluminium concentration.
Heavy metal poisoning presenting with chronic abdominal pain
Abdominal pain is a commonly encountered presenting symptom in general practice.
Common causes of acute abdominal pain can be attributed to infective, surgical,
and gynaecological or obstetrical aetiologies, while chronic abdominal pain may
be caused by constipation, peptic ulcer, inflammatory bowel disease, and psychological
complications of organic diseases.15 Although tactful history and thorough
physical examination can assist clinicians to narrow down these differential diagnoses,
laboratory investigations are often required to confirm the initial clinical suspicion.
Case 3
A 31-year old Caucasian businessman complained of feeling dizzy on exertion, nausea,
poor appetite, low abdominal pain, generalised muscle and joint pain, and constipation
over a month. He was admitted to hospital for investigation. Physical examination
showed pallor and low abdominal tenderness.
His haemoglobin concentration was 8.6g/dL (normal 11.0-14.2) with markedly elevated
reticulocyte count of 5.9% (normal <1.0) and mild basophilic stippling. Serum liver
function test showed elevated total bilirubin concentration of 38mmol/L (normal
<15) and alanine aminotransferase activity at 119 IU/L (normal <58). Hepatitis A,
B, and C serologies were all negative. Serum haptoglobin concentration, lactate
dehydrogenase activity, and direct and indirect Coombs' tests were also normal.
As the patient is a Caucasian, acute porphyria was suspected. Urine and stool were
collected for total porphyrins, d-aminolaevulinic acid (d-ALA) and porphobilinogen
(PBG) studies during the time of abdominal pain reported:
|
|
Urine and stool total porphyrins
|
:
|
positive
|
|
|
Urine d-ALA
|
:
|
positive
|
|
|
Urine PBG
|
:
|
negative
|
Does he suffer from acute porphyria?
Interpretation
This patient was suffering from lead poisoning instead of acute porphyria. Lead,
like other toxic heavy metals, binds to sulphydryl group of protein molecules causing
functional inactivation. In the haem biosynthetic pathway (Figure 1), lead inhibits the activities
of d-ALA dehydratase, coproporphyrinogen decarboxylase, and ferrochelatase causing
an increase in d-ALA (accounting for increase in its urine concentration), copropor-phyrinogen
III, and protoporphyrin IX concentrations (accounting for increase in urine and
stool total porphyrins). Decreased haem biosynthesis eventually results in decreased
blood haemoglobin concentration. Feedback inhibition of haemoglobin on d-ALA synthetase
is thus removed causing more d-ALA to be synthesised. Inhibition of d-ALA dehydratase
is one of the earliest sign of lead poisoning occurring at blood lead concentration
of 0.5mmol/L.
Although the clinical signs and symptoms of acute porphyrias are similar to those
found in lead poisoning including abdominal pain, constipation, and peripheral motor
neuropathy, they can be distinguished biochemically. Urine PBG is not significantly
elevated in lead poisoning but increased in all types of acute porphyrias including
acute intermittent porphyria (AIP), porphyria variegata (PV), and hereditary coproporphyria
(HC). Urine d-ALA (a neurotoxin) is elevated in both lead poisoning and acute porphyrias
limiting its usefulness in the biochemical investigation. Urine total porphyrins
are increased in lead poisoning and hepatic porphyrias, as well as other diseases
including erythropoietic porphyrias, infectious hepatitis, cirrhosis, haemochromatosis,
acute and chronic alcoholism, haemolytic, aplastic and pernicious anaemias.
The daily intake of lead is about 1mmol via drinking water and 1mmol from food.
Once absorbed, lead rapidly accumulates in erythrocytes (95 %) with a half-life
of 35 days before it is passed into the urine or is transferred to soft tissues
including hair, nail, alimentary secretion, and finally to bone tissue containing
99% of the total body lead burden but turning over slowly. Therefore, the laboratory
investigation of choice is whole blood lead while urine lead excretion rate should
be used for monitoring chelation therapy.
In this patient, the blood lead concentration was 3.15mmol/L (normal <0.48mmol/L).12
Other heavy metals were not elevated. His urine total protein concentration was
less than 0.1g/L indicating the absence of significant renal damage. He had recently
travelled to India with his Indian wife who gave him 5 different kinds of traditional
medicinal drugs as aphrodisiacs. One of these 5 drugs was analysed to contain about
2800 ppm of lead (normal allowable limit <0.1).16 He was advised to stop
all these drugs and was successfully treated with chelation therapy using 2,3-dimercaptosuccinic
acid (DMSA).17
Local cases of mercury poisoning
Like lead, mercury is an environmental toxin. Three forms exist naturally: elemental,
inorganic, and organic, with methyl mercury representing the prototype of the organic
form of mercury compounds. In western societies, mercurial compounds have been used
historically as anti-microbial agent,18 especially in the treatment of
syphilis.19,20 Not until 1955, calomel (mercurous chloride) was detected
in teething powders and worm medication in the United Kingdom.21 It was
responsible for the poisoning of a large number of children after dental treatment
(Pink disease).22 Thereafter, the Minamata incident in Japan remains
the best known example of massive mercury poisoning in humans due to excessive discharge
of contaminated industrial wastes into the aquatic environment.23,24
Mercury poisoning in fungicide-users is an example of occupational risk. Over-exposure
can also occur with industrial accidents resulting in pneumonitis due to its volatile
nature.25
Mercury is known as 「汞」 or 「水銀」 in Chinese. A number of Chinese medicinal compounds
contain inorganic mercury salts. The inorganic form can exist in more than 30 kinds
of mineral and medicinal compounds as well as mixtures of compounds including mercury
sulphide(辰砂,三方晶系;黑辰砂,等軸晶系),mercury-antimony ore(天然汞,硫汞銻礦),mercury-antimony-copper
ore(汞黑幼礦),mercuric or mercurous chloride(降丹,水火丹,升汞,輕粉), mercury oxide (三仙丹,升丹,小升丹,靈藥,三白丹,三仙散,紅升,黃升,紅粉,升藥底)。
Calomel was commonly used as a cathartic because soluble mercuric ions were thought
to inhibit the re-absorption of sodium and other ions in the intestines leading
to retention of electrolytes and water in the bowel. Its aqueous solution has been
used as a fungicide for the topical treatment of various skin diseases. It can be
used topically with realgar for skin infection. In western medicine, all species
of mercury are considered as toxic. Organic mercury is readily absorbed through
our diet from contaminated seafood. This is the most common source of contacting
mercury in daily life. Inorganic mercury is corrosive to the mucous membrane, while
exposure to elemental mercury is usually by accident either in the industry, hospital,
or through deliberate self-harm.
After absorption, elemental mercury is ultimately converted in vivo by the action
of catalase, to the active inorganic mercury ions (Hg2+) that bind avidly
to the sulphydryl group of most proteins and enzymes where the active sites are
situated and render them inactive. Mercuric ions also displace other divalent metal
ions such as copper ion from active sites thereby inhibiting the oxidative-reductive
reactions. Organic mercury is demethylated to mercuric ions, which will then exert
the same toxic effects. Organic and elemental mercury are even more toxic as they
readily pass through the blood-brain-barrier as well as placenta. Therefore, the
foetus, babies, and developing children are at an increased risk of mental side
effects. The acute load of mercury will be handled by our renal system. It is not
surprising that the kidney is another target organ for damage. Tubular damage can
result in proteinuria and even nephrotic syndrome.26 Therefore, urinary
excretion rate is the most appropriate parameter for monitoring chelation therapy.
Acute poisoning with elemental mercury will cause severe pneumonitis and adult respiratory
distress syndrome. Elemental mercury is well absorbed through the pulmonary vasculature.
Shock and acute renal failure will then follow 4-12 days after initial exposure.
For acute poisoning with inorganic mercury, mucous membrane ulceration, excessive
salivation, nausea, vomiting, abdominal pain, diarrhoea, lethargy, oliguria or even
anuria may be resulted. Complications such as gastrointestinal bleeding, acute renal
failure, and circulatory failure can sometimes result in fatality. In chronic poisoning
with organic mercury and other mercury species, the signs and symptoms are less
well demarcated. Mild symptoms like back and joint pain are very common. Neuropathy,
mental disturbance, tunnel vision, etc, represent late and ominous signs of chronic
intoxication. Therefore, the best marker for the laboratory diagnosis of acute and
chronic mercury poisoning is whole blood mercury collected in certified specimen
bottles.
Case 4
A 38-year old housewife presented with a laboratory report showing markedly elevated
hair mercury content of 22.5mg/g (normal 11.6). Her family doctor had requested
the test because of her low back pain and previous occupation in an electroplating
factory 13 years ago. Other toxic metals such as lead, cadmium, arsenic and thallium
were within normal limits. She denied any colouring or permanent wave treatment
of hair before the sample was taken. On examination there was no psychosis, neuropathy,
dermopathy or arthropathy. However, her blood mercury (94nmol/L, normal
45)17 and urine mercury excretion (345
nmol/day, normal 50)12 were elevated, while other biochemical and haemato-logical
investigations were normal. As she consumed a typical Chinese diet containing fish
caught near local industrial areas, she was advised to avoid seafood. Four weeks
later her blood mercury concentration had decreased to 77nmol/L, which was still
high. She volunteered that she has been using a skin-whitening cosmetic cream twice
daily over her face for several months. She was also advised to stop using this
cream. Two weeks later, her blood mercury concentration had decreased markedly to
25 nmol/L, which was well below the upper reference value, while the daily urine
mercury output was still high (313 nmol/day), indicating ongoing excretion of the
mercury load.
Further investigation
The offending cream was found to contain an extremely high mercury content at 6.5%
w/w, that is, 65,000 ppm (normal <1).27 The mercury species in this cream
was found to be largely inorganic (95.3%).
Interpretation
A survey of mercury content for locally available beauty creams and cosmetics has
been published.28 Consumers should be careful and selective in purchasing
beauty creams and other cosmetics. They should prefer products that are manufactured
in developed countries, where regulations for quality control and product labelling
are more stringent before export. Price should not be the principal concern in their
selection, and they should be aware of fake or pirated products. Family physicians
and other specialists should be aware that patients might be exposed to widely available
and easily purchased cosmetics and other products that are adulterated or contaminated
with heavy metals such as mercury, lead, cadmium, and arsenic, and be alert to the
possibility of chronic heavy metal poisoning with vague and non-specific signs and
symptoms. In suspected cases, they should refer the patients for heavy metal analysis
and other appropriate laboratory investigations including a complete blood count
and renal function test.
Case 5
A 5-year old Chinese boy of healthy unrelated parents presented on two occasions:
(i) initially with oral ulceration. Herpetic ulceration was diagnosed and confirmed
by the isolation of herpes simplex virus (HSV) type 1 from his tongue swab. The
lesion improved after treatment with a 5-day course of oral acyclovir; and (ii)
sudden onset of motor tics consisting of eye blinking, head turning, and shoulder
shrugging 5 weeks later. On examination, there were episodes of motor tics as described.
No skin rash or desquamation on the palms and soles was noted. There was a small
healing ulcer at the tip of his tongue. His speech and gait were normal. Cardiovascular,
respiratory, abdominal, and neurological examinations did not reveal any abnormalities.
Sensory and motor nerve conduction velocities were reported to be normal. Other
investigations including complete blood count, renal function tests and electrolytes,
liver enzymes, immunoglobulins, complements, as well as urinalysis and toxicology
screening were all normal. Serum anti-neuronal antibody and anti-streptolysin O
titre were not elevated. Electroencephalography, cranial computerised tomography,
and magnetic resonance imaging of the brain were also normal.
However, his blood mercury concentration was found to be 83 nmol/L (normal
45).17
Interpretation
This patient had been on a normal unrestricted diet and there was no history of
excessive seafood consumption. On further questioning, his mother admitted that
the patient had been given a Chinese medicinal mouth spray, named "Watermelon Frost
(西瓜霜)", 20 times daily for 4 weeks preceding the second admission. The spray was
believed to be useful in controlling pain and healing mucosal wounds. After abstinence
from the use of the offending mouth spray for 4 weeks, blood mercury concentration
had decreased to below the normal reference interval with resolution of his motor
tics.29 The mercury content of the spray was 878 ppm (normal allowable
limit <1).27 The mercury species in this mouth spray was again found
to be largely inorganic (98%).
Mouth ulceration is one of the most common problems encountered in general practice.
Most mouth ulcers are caused by Herpes Simplex Virus Type 1. Healing usually occurs
with time. Acyclovir can be prescribed as an anti-viral therapy in severe cases
but it is quite expensive. In our local population, alternative medicine are often
used which could be adulterated with western medicine purposefully or contaminated
with unwanted substances such as heavy metals unintentionally during sub-standard
manufacturing process. Family physicians and other specialists should always be
alert of the signs and symptoms as well as the possibility of heavy metals poisoning.
Industrial over-exposure or contamination of cadmium and cobalt at the workplace
Unlike lead or mercury, industrial exposure of cadmium and cobalt is a recently
noticed phenomenon. The processes of smelting and refining of zinc and lead ores
produce dust and vapour laden with cadmium. Electroplating, soldering, brazing and
the disposal of industrial waste also generate cadmium-rich vapour and dust. Other
sources of cadmium are from diet including shellfish, animal kidneys, and tobacco.
The gastrointestinal absorption of cadmium is variable depending on the intake of
other divalent nutritional metals as they share the same carrier for absorption.
Once absorbed, cadmium is transported within the plasma to liver where it is combined
with metallothionein which will then be re-distributed to the renal cortex slowly
via glomerular filtration and tubular reabsorption. Whole blood cadmium concentration
is therefore a better index of exposure as urine cadmium excretion is usually normal
until renal damage has occurred.
Exposure of inorganic cobalt can occur during production of tungsten carbide materials,
manufacture of alloys and pigments, and corrosion of cobalt-alloy joint prosthesis.
Cobalt can cause cardiomyopathy resulting in fulminating heart failure and polycythaemia.
Hard metal interstitial lung disease can also occur following occupational exposure
of cobalt powder or vapour. Unlike cadmium, inorganic cobalt exposure requires urinary
assessment as it is rapidly excreted in urine within 2-3 days after initial exposure.30
The Occupational Safety & Health Branch of the Labour Department of Hong Kong as
well as the Occupational Safety & Health Council have jointly published guidance
notes on medical examinations for workers engaged in hazardous occupations in industrial
undertakings in November 2003. Workers at risk of contacting toxic metals are recommended
to have regular and appropriate medical check-up including chest radiograph, lung
function, audiometric, blood, and urine tests for the assessment of industrial over-exposure
and early detection of complications. The panel of heavy metals includes arsenic,
cadmium, manganese, lead, and mercury.31
Case 6
Three workers in a battery manufacturing factory had their yearly laboratory assessment:
Biochemical test
|
|
M / 47
|
|
M / 35
|
|
M / 42
|
Blood cadmium
(non-smoker <27nmol/L; smoker <54nmol/L)12
|
|
49
|
|
143
|
|
87
|
Urine cadmium/creatinine ratio
(<10.0 nmol/mmol creatinine)12
|
|
6.6
|
|
25.3
|
|
11.4
|
Urine cobalt/creatinine ratio
(<2.1 nmol/mmol creatinine)32
|
|
6.5
|
|
9.1
|
|
4.0
|
Urine
-2-microglobulin/ creatinine ratio
(<170.0 mg/mmol creatinine)
|
|
39.2
|
|
13.5
|
|
167.0
|
Cadmium concentration of control water sample
(<0.3 nmol/L)
|
|
<0.3
|
|
<0.3
|
|
<0.3
|
Cobalt concentration of control water sample
(<0.24 nmol/L)
|
|
<0.24
|
|
<0.24
|
|
<0.24
|
Interpretation
All three workers had a significant exposure of cobalt but only two of them had
significant exposure of cadmium. It is important to note the smoking habit of these
workers in order to interpret the blood cadmium results correctly because the reference
intervals for smokers and non-smokers are totally different. All workers showed
normal urine b-2-microglobulin to creatinine ratio indicating the absence of renal
damage even though they had had a significant exposure. Control samples were collected
by instructing workers to decant double distilled water standard using their own
hands to specimen bottles for excluding the possibility of false positive result
due to environmental contamination during sample collection.
Conclusion
In conclusion, the following approach is recommended for investigating patients
with suspected heavy metal poisoning:
(i) Identification of possible source(s) of exposure
Occupational, drug and dietary histories as well as personal habits are important
information to note.1 If possible, obtain the remains of the suspicious
drug, cosmetics, and food for future analysis.
(ii) Laboratory diagnosis
Clinical manifestation of heavy metal poisoning is often protean with signs and
symptoms that are often subtle and ill-defined. Proper diagnosis depends very much
on the clinical acumen of the attending clinicians and a thoroughly taken medical
history. In the absence of probable cause such as occupational and/or accidental
environmental exposure, broad-spectrum screening for trace elements and other analytes
is inappropriate and would rarely be indicated in general practice.33
Proper laboratory investigations serve to confirm the diagnosis. If necessary, analysis
of the offending drug, cosmetics or food can also be performed.26,28,29
However, contamination is a major challenge to laboratories performing trace element
analysis. Quality results require good pre-analytical preparation. Obtaining instructions
for sample collection and certified specimen bottles from a reputable laboratory
that has participated in regular quality assurance programme for trace element analysis
is essential.
(iii) Assessment of complications
Renal toxicity with tubular cell damage resulting in significant proteinuria is
common. Urine retinol binding protein or b-2-microglobulin normalised to creatinine
can be requested as an objective assessment of tubular proteinuria. Central nervous
system is another common site affected by heavy metals such as lead and mercury
after they have crossed the blood-brain-barrier. Nerve conduction study can be requested
as a non-invasive but objective measurement of the neurotoxic effects of heavy metal
deposition.
(iv) Chelation therapy
This depends very much on the severity, toxic signs and symptoms. Advantages and
disadvantages of the chelation therapy have to be considered thoroughly and discussed
with the patient since chelation therapy may have deleterious side effects.34
Key messages
- The diagnosis of heavy metal poisoning requires a high index of suspicion substantiated
by careful collection of patient information (occupational and drug histories, dietary
and other personal habits), and targeted investigations.
- Laboratory investigations require the use of correct specimen containers and sample
type(s) with appropriate pre-analytical precautions.
- Assistance or advice can be obtained from a reputable chemical pathology laboratory
capable of providing both the analytical service and result interpretation.
Michael H M Chan, MBChB(CUHK), FRCPA, FHKCPath, FHKAM(Pathology)
Deputising Senior Medical Officer,
Robert C K Cheung, PhD(CUHK)
Scientific Officer (Medical),
Eric C W Lam, MBChB(CUHK), PhD(CUHK), FRCPA, FHKAM(Pathology)
Associate Professor,
Christopher W K Lam, PhD(S'ton), FRSC(UK), FACB(USA)
Chairman and Chief-of-Service,
Department of Chemical Pathology, The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Prince of
Wales Hospital.
Albert Y W Chan, MBChB(Glasg), MD(CUHK), FHKCP, FHKCPath
Consultant Chemical Pathologist,
Department of Pathology, Princess Margaret Hospital.
Tony W L Mak, MBChB(CUHK), MBA, FRCPA, FHKAM(Pathology)
Consultant,
Department of Clinical Pathology, Tuen Mun Hospital.
Anthony C C Shek, MBBS(HK), FRCPath, FRCPA, FHKAM(Pathology)
Consultant,
Department of Pathology, Queen Elizabeth Hospital.
Sidney Tam, FRCP(Edin), FRCPA, FHKAM(Medicine), FHKAM(Pathology)
Head and Consultant,
Division of Clinical Biochemistry, Department of Pathology, Queen Mary Hospital.
Correspondence to : Prof Christopher W K Lam, Department of Chemical Pathology,
The Chinese University of Hong Kong, Prince of Wales Hospital, Shatin, N.T., Hong
Kong.
Email : waikeilam@cuhk.edu.hk
References
- Baldwin DR, Marshall WJ. Heavy metal poisoning and its laboratory investigation.
Ann Clin Biochem 1999;36:267-300.
- Harada M. Minamata disease: methyl mercury poisoning in Japan caused by environmental
pollution. Crit Rev Toxicol 1995;25:1-24.
- Food and Drug Administration, USA. Seafood information and resources. http://vm.cfsan.fda.gov/seafood1.html.
Online resources dated 19 March 2004.
- Department of Health, The Government of Hong Kong Special Administrative Region.
Lead poisoning due to ingestion of herbal pill "Bao Ning Dan". Circular to doctors
dated 5 February 2001.
- Taylor A. Usefulness of measurements of trace elements in hair. Ann Clin Biochem
1986;23:364-378.
- Hac E, Krechniak J. Mercury concentrations in hair exposed to mercury vapour. Bio
Trace Element Res 1993;39:109-115.
- Poon WT, Ling SC, Chan AY, et al. Use of hair analysis in the diagnosis of heavy
metal poisoning: report of three cases. Hong Kong Med J 2004;10:197-200.
- Ip P, Ko P, Lam C, et al. Hong Kong College of Paediatricians position paper on
exposure to lead and mercury in children and chelation therapy. Hong Kong J Paediatr
2004;9:101-102.
- Time Asia Magazine. Death on flight 974: Who was responsible for the poisoning of
one of the Indonesia's bravest human-rights activists? http://www.time.com/time/asia/magazine/article/0,13673,501041206-832296,00.html.
Online resources dated 6 December 2004.
- Keys JD. Chinese herbs: their botany, chemistry, and pharmacodynamics. Hong Kong;
Swindon 1976;297-301.
- Tietz NW. Fundamentals of Clinical Chemistry, 2nd ed. Philadelphia; W.B. Saunders
1976;1207.
- Walker AW. Clinical and analytical handbook of trace element analyses. Guildford;
NHS Supra-regional Assay Service, Royal Surry County & St Luke's Hospital, UK 1992.
- Nixon DE, Moyer TP. Arsenic analysis II: rapid separation and quantification of
inorganic arsenic plus metabolites and arsenobetaine in urine. Clin Chem 1992;38:2479-2483.
- Becaria A, Campbell A, Bondy SC. Aluminium as a toxicant. Toxicol Ind Health 2002;18:309-320.
- Stone R. Acute abdominal pain. Lippincotts Prim Care Pract 1998;2:341-357.
- Food and Drug Administration, USA. Letter to manufacturers, importers, and distributors
of imported candy. http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/%7Edms/pbltr.html. Online resources
dated 25 March 2004.
- Goldfrank LR, Flomenbaum NE, Lewin NA, et al. Goldfrank's Toxicologic Emergencies,
6th ed. Stamford; Appleton & Lange 1998;1319-1331.
- Mentin-Gil J, Delibes de Castro G, Zapatero-Megdalero P, et al. Preserving the ancients
with vermilion. Lancet 1994;344:1776.
- Sartin JS, Perry HO. From mercury to malaria to penicillin: the history of the treatment
of syphilis at the Mayo Clinic 1916-1955. J Am Acad Dermatol 1995;32:255-261.
- Weismann K. Neurosyphilis, or chronic heavy metal poisoning: Karen Blixen's lifelong
disease. Sex Transm Dis 1995;22:137-144.
- Hendry WF, A'Hern RP, Cole PJ. Was Young's syndrome caused by exposure to mercury
in childhood? BMJ 1993;307:1579-1582.
- Stephenson JBP. Pink disease. BMJ 1966;1:1110-1111.
- Tsuchiya K. The discovery of the causative agent of Minamata disease. Am J Ind Med
1992;21:275-280.
- Southcott RV. The neurologic effects of noxious marine creatures. Contemp Neurol
Ser 1975;12:165-258.
- Lodenius M, Malm O. Mercury in Amazon. Rev Environ Contam Toxicol 1998;157:25-52.
- Soo YO, Chow KM, Lam CWK, et al. A whitened face woman with nephrotic syndrome.
Am J Kid Dis 2003;41:250-253.
- Food and Drug Administration, USA. Prohibited ingredients and related safety issues.
http://www.cfsan.fda.gov/~dms/cos-210.html. Online resources dated 30 March 2000.
- Chan MHM, Cheung RCK, Chan IHS, et al. An unusual case of mercury intoxication.
Brit J Dermatol 2001;144:192-194.
- Li AM, Chan MHM, Leung TF, et al. Mercury intoxication presenting with tics. Arch
Dis Child 2000;83:174-175.
- White MA, Dyne D. Biological monitoring of occupational cobalt exposure in the United
Kingdom. Sci Total Environ 1994;150:209-213.
- Labour Department, Occupational Safety & Health Council. Guidance notes on medical
examinations for workers engaged in hazardous occupations in industrial undertakings.
http://www.labour.gov.hk/eng/public/oh/ENG.pdf. Online resources dated 10 November
2003.
- Trace Element & Micronutrient Reference Laboratory. Sample requirements and reference
values for cobalt. http://www.trace-elements.org.uk/cobalt.htm. Online resources
dated 17 June 2004.
- Wu AH, McKay C, Broussard LA, et al. National academy of clinical biochemistry laboratory
medicine practice guidelines: recommendations for the use of laboratory tests to
support poisoned patients who present to the emergency department. Clin Chem 2003;49:357-379.
- Andersen O. Chemical and biological considerations in the treatment of metal intoxications
by chelating agents. Mini Rev Med Chem 2004;4:11-21.
|